Impact of Market Downturns on Fixed Equity Indexed Annuity Crediting Methods

Posted by Joshua Greenberg on Apr 09 2025 16:21

Understanding Fixed Equity Indexed Annuities

Fixed equity indexed annuities (FEIAs) are popular financial products that combine the benefits of fixed annuities with the growth potential of equity markets. They offer a unique way to grow your retirement savings while providing a safety net against market downturns. The way returns are credited in an FEIA is crucial, especially during market fluctuations, as it influences the overall performance of your investment.

Types of Crediting Methods in FEIAs

FEIAs typically utilize several crediting methods. These include the annual point-to-point method, monthly sum, and high water mark, among others. Each method calculates interest credits differently based on the market index performance and can affect your overall returns.

Annual Point-to-Point Method

This common method measures the change in the index from the beginning to the end of the contract year. During a market downturn, if the index value is lower at the end of the year compared to the beginning, this method might yield little to no crediting. However, since the principal is protected, the investor does not lose the accumulated value of the annuity itself.

Monthly Sum Method

In this method, returns are determined by adding the monthly changes in the index. A downturn can cause months with significant negative index returns to offset positive months, potentially resulting in zero or minimal returns for the year. This method’s vulnerability during volatile markets makes it less ideal for conservative investors during downturns.

High Water Mark Method

This method looks at the highest index value reached during the contract term and calculates the interest based on this point. In a declining market, it might still offer attractive returns if there was a peak early on. However, frequent market downturns mean the high point might not be significantly higher than the starting point, affecting potential gains.

Navigating Market Downturns with FEIAs

The strength of an FEIA lies in its ability to protect the principal from loss, despite how the market performs. While the returns may not be as high as during a bull market, the assurance of not losing original investment capital offers peace of mind. Advisors often recommend maintaining a diversified portfolio to manage the risks, even when investing in FEIAs.

By understanding how each crediting method works, investors can choose options that best align with their risk tolerance and financial goals, especially when navigating uncertain market conditions.

About the Author

Josh Greenberg is the founder of Green Bee Insurance, a Fort Lauderdale–based Medicare and retirement planning firm serving clients across Florida. Since 2014, he has helped individuals approaching retirement compare Medicare plans, coordinate Social Security decisions, and align healthcare choices with their retirement income strategy. His approach focuses on clear education and structured plan reviews built around each client’s doctors, prescriptions, and long-term financial goals.

Tatyana T.

Professional, knowledgeable, friendly and always helpful. Highly recommended.

Wayne K.

very knowledgeable and not pushy

Brett S.

I needed more Life insurance and was considering a Variable annuity policy, and Josh & Green Bee came highly recommended by one of my colleagues. Josh was excellent. He educated me on my options, and I found him to be consultative, compassionate, and a genuine professional—overall, just the right person for my family's insurance needs.

Jorge C.

Knowledgeable and trustworthy.

David D.

A pleasure to do business with. I will even recommend Josh to my children for their insurance needs. A true professional.

Daniel F.

Josh in an outstanding advisor to work with. I would highly recommend him to anyone interested in reviewing their insurances

Matthew W.

Josh is extremely knowledgeable and easy to work with. He makes the whole process simple and takes the time to answer all questions that I have. I would highly recommend working from Green Bee Insurance.

Jayson C.

Josh is my work neighbor, which has provided me with a unique third-party perspective on who he is as an individual. After working with him as a fellow professional, I've come to realize that this easy to get along with person definitely knows his stuff. I highly recommend him for any Medicare, retirement planning, or long-term care advisement services!

Patricia F.

Have always had a pleasant experience when dealing with Josh. He has always tried to help me with mine and my husbands insurance needs.

Dante N.

Josh had great recommendations and really explained all of my options to. I had no idea what I was looking for, and he made it easy and quick. Highly recommend him!

Donna V.

Green Bee Insurance, representative Joshua Greenberg, is the best insurance company I ever dealt with. Josh is truly a professional. He takes his time with you to see what your needs are. His suggestions are wonderful, and he gets you the best insurance rates and policy that he can find. He is always looking out for your best interest. He checks in with you to see if you are happy with your decision. Very understanding and caring. Not your typical insurance company or rep. He found insurance for my husband and myself showing the utmost care in what would be best for our individual needs. He's the best in my book!

Robin B.

Josh was very helpful to find us insurance. Explained everything thoroughly. I would definitely recommend his services.

Sam G.

Outstanding

ET

Josh is very.knowlegable and informative.

Michael N.

This guy knows his business, he made the process easy and digestable